top of page

PASTORAL EVALUATION

28 minutes ago
3 min read

Fr Billy Swan


In a recent address to the Diocese of Rome, Pope Leo XIV spoke about how ‘The Synodal Journey has taught us how to listen and discern together, as co-responsible for the one mission’. He then added: ‘I would like to propose that we develop another dimension: that of pastoral evaluation’.


He then went on to describe what this evaluation looks like. It is a synodal exercise, in the light of the Holy Spirit, to discern where our energies as parishes are going, “to recognise what has born fruit, to understand what has not worked and to seek the reasons for this together”. He then presented a series of questions that every parish could ask itself: “Do our activities encourage growth in faith? Do they form missionary disciples? Do they help develop ecclesial responsibility? Do they foster a mature faith, capable of translating into concrete choices of life and service?” (Pope Leo XIV, St John Lateran’s, 18th September 2026).


Like Ireland, the Italian Church faces similar challenges with low retention of young people in parish communities, having celebrated the sacraments of initiation. The Pope is aware of these challenges and seeks to offer leadership and encouragement. His words invite every parish back to the basic question of why we do what we do, as Church? For example, what is the goal of a First Communion or Confirmation programme? What do we hope will be the fruit of it all?


In the same address, the Pope does not focus on what we do or what we change, as much as ‘whom and how to encounter’. For Leo, ‘it is not enough to ask whether an activity is well organised, whether it is well attended, or whether it has been running for many years’. He says: ‘We must ask whether it truly leads to Christ, whether it brings the Gospel into contact with the real lives’ of the people’.


The guidance of the Holy Father is timely and can be summed up in three points that speak to our parishes today. First, discerning the fruitfulness of our sacramental programmes, or lack of fruitfulness, is not something very important and is something that priests can do on their own. Understandably, priests become disillusioned when so few families and young people stay connected to parish communities once the celebration of these sacraments are over. Therefore, we must discern together why this is the case. Only together as laity, clergy and religious can we face up to the reasons why people are staying or not and ask the question of whether or not our communities are producing missionary disciples. This is the key question because the future of faith communities depends on ‘new blood’ coming through.


Second, through the sacramental programmes of parishes and as people committed to faith encounter many on the margins, how can we offer them the warmth and joy of Jesus Christ? Do we welcome the opportunity to share our faith joyfully and generously? The Church does not exist for her own sake, but to lead every person to an encounter with the Lord.


Thirdly, the Holy Father directs our hearts and minds to a greater clarity on what sacramental programmes are about – to produce intentional missionary disciples with a mature faith that translates into choices and lives of service. This clarity is welcome at a time when there is such a diversity in perspectives about what sacramental occasions represent – from merely social and traditional events, to rites of passage, to sacred moments on the journey of faith. All of these are valid but, as Pope Leo reminds us, the formation of the People of God comes first as communities are born and renewed by a fidelity to the Gospel that generates the future.


This is the lens through which we discern and decide to retain how we do things or whether we ‘thrown the net out to starboard and you will find something’ (John 21:6) – that is, to try a new way of bringing the Gospel into contact with the real lives of people.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page